Good Guys Pizza in Nortd Tonawanda

Good Guys Pizza in Nortd Tonawanda
4.5 / 5
49 reviews

1248 Ruie Rd, Nortd Tonawanda, NY 14120-2226, Nortd Tonawanda

Overview

Cuisine
  • Pizza
  • Italian
Features
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

Do they take credit/debit cards

They do take credit/ debit cards!!

When are they going to add a location closer to Kenmore? Best pizza on the planet!

I haven't heard of any plans like that , but keep your fingers crossed !.

Do you ship pizza?

Pick up orders as far as I know. If you are out of state you might want to call and ask maybe they would work something out.

Do they have gift certificates available?

Yes I bought one for my niece for her Birthday last year.

Do they deliver?

Greg is wrong, they have never delivered and still do not.

Can we eat in restaurant or is it just take out?

Just take out

Can you order online?

No can't order online. But it's the best pizza in North Tonawanda, and they also don't deliver due to high volume. It's worth it though

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Good Guys Pizza
BP
Beth Pf
google
11.06.2024
5/5

Chicken finger pizza was super good! Everything was cooked well, I LOVE the crust. You can't get a yeasty thick crust much any more....I appreciate that 👍👍👍

Good Guys Pizza
TR
T Ravi
google
10.07.2018
5/5

Didn’t order food from them but amazing customer service. Was delivering for grubhub and they forgot to make one of the pizzas and offered instead that they deliver it So I don’t have to wait even though they don’t deliver and even gave me a free lunch as I waited. Some of the nicest customer service.

Good Guys Pizza
PA
Patricia Aldridge-Monroe
google
09.02.2018
1/5

Denied service from owner not workersI personally went in and ordered 2 slices of cheese pizza when I got home it had pepperoni on both slices, I returned and was told by the owner that they dont sell cheese only slices, I had been buying cheese slices for over a year with no problem and it is listed on the menu. The only difference was the owner served me, i no longer spend my hard earned money in that establishment and have encouraged others like myself to do the same

Good Guys Pizza
JP
Julian Pearson
google
06.14.2018
3/5

If you ask the locals around here, they will tell you that this is the best pizza they ever had. But for me it was just ok and very filling. So it got the job done. Nice size slices too

Good Guys Pizza
TD
Tony DeWitt
google
06.14.2018
5/5

We are from out of town and walked in to get a pizza and salad. The staff was very friendly and courteous. The pizza was excellent in every way, thick and crunchy crust, but not heavy, good sauce, and loads of cheese. One of the best pizzas I've had in a while.

Good Guys Pizza
AC
Amy Carozzolo
google
05.18.2018
5/5

Best food around! Can't beat the quality of there food.

Good Guys Pizza
SR
Samantha Rochester
google
05.13.2018
5/5

Love the food here. They are no shy about toppings and cheese. Even if theres a mix up Good Guys always make it right.

Good Guys Pizza
MO
Matt Olka
google
04.21.2018
5/5

Hands down best pizza in WNY. Their best is a half sheet. Seams to cook the best compared to their large round pizza. Blue cheese is also some of the best.. not watered down or too raunchy tasting. Subs and wings are decent also. This place is consistent. Never under turnover cooled and the one time they over cooked my pizza they gave me half for free. Owner is almost always there and makes good deals on huge orders.

Good Guys Pizza
FR
Francis Remond
google
04.02.2018
1/5

We've ordered two weeks in a row .got there and our order wasn't there .said I didn't call lol .the owners need to get competent people working behind counter and answering phones for orders I drove a long way for that pizza and fingers

Good Guys Pizza
SK
Shane Keyes
google
03.02.2018
5/5

Best Pizza and wings in North Tonawanda and probably in Buffalo area! Monster big salads that are awesome too! They do NOT deliver.

Good Guys Pizza
dk
david kubiniec
google
02.16.2018
5/5

Best pizza ever won't b hungry after

Good Guys Pizza
LF
LC Fesco
google
02.10.2018
5/5

My favorite pizza! The crust! The cheese! The pepp! What are you waiting for? Try it ❤️

Good Guys Pizza
JP
John Perry
google
02.09.2018
5/5

Absolutely one of the best pizza's I've ever had. With a thick crust to hold onto, and plenty of toppings to fill you up I was full after two slices! I recommend you try pepperoni and sausage! 😁

Good Guys Pizza
JH
Jason Hurley
google
01.23.2018
4/5

Very good pizza with a lot of toppings, but it did have a bit too much cheese.

Good Guys Pizza
AM
Antonio Miles
google
01.22.2018
5/5

Great service and good food!😋

Good Guys Pizza
AG
Anne Garner
google
01.22.2018
3/5

We live around the corner and we order from good guys all the time. I would’ve given it five stars because your food is amazing! However when we ordered from there tonight I felt that the girl on the phone had an attitude not friendly at all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I am in the restaurant business and that I would never tolerate. Then when my husband came to pick up the pizza she also had an attitude. The food however was amazing but I just wanted to inform you.

Good Guys Pizza
MN
Matthew Noakes
google
11.10.2017
5/5

Always good food! Pizza is great, wings are fantastic! If you don't like thicker pizza get the NY style....it's just as good as the regular pizza!

Good Guys Pizza
DO
Doug Orlowski
google
11.02.2017
5/5

Great food with large portions

Good Guys Pizza
AS
Anthony Salhab
google
09.22.2017
5/5

Great pizza.thick n crusty..sauce delicious..well made

Good Guys Pizza
RP
Randy Pollow
google
09.21.2017
5/5

Worth the trip from Lockport , I will definitely go back !!!

Good Guys Pizza
Bl
Bathtech llc
google
09.18.2017
5/5

Best pizza best wings and there subs are unbelievable I order from there all the time and everything is the best in wny

Good Guys Pizza
TL
Terry L
google
08.09.2017
5/5

The assorted Sub is phenomenal!!! Greek Pizza Rocks.

Good Guys Pizza
AM
Adam Medbury
google
06.25.2017
5/5

Bozanna's in Clarence and Sgt. Pepperoni's in Depew were my go to pizza joints until they closed. Since then I have been unable to find a pizza place to match their style of pizza. Well last night I drove 35 mins from Lancaster to Good Guys and from this day forward I will be making that drive everytime I want pizza. The pizza was amazing and exactly like Bozanna's and Sgt. P's. Great job Good Guys.

Good Guys Pizza
CF
Christopher Foster
google
06.03.2017
5/5

First time buyer. Really good pizza

Good Guys Pizza
MR
Matthew Ruch
google
05.26.2017
5/5

The Best pizza around. I defy anybody to get better bang for your buck than here. The slices are large and the toppings generous. There is a good chance that a single slice will leave you full, but who can eat just one. The other options, wings and subs are also very good. You can't go wrong here

Good Guys Pizza
CG
Cameron Graham
google
05.08.2017
4/5

Good wigs but the pizza is not that good 5 stars for the wigs and 3 star's for the pizza

Good Guys Pizza
DD
David Drake
google
05.03.2017
1/5

Over price ny style large pie they didn’t cut the slices good barely visible pizza falling all apart shouldn’t have to eat with fork like lasagna cause the all the toppings are Dropping off

Good Guys Pizza
MR
Michael Roberts
google
04.18.2017
5/5

Best pizza in town. Not cheap but you get what you pay for.

Good Guys Pizza
SP
Steve Perna
google
04.14.2017
5/5

I have had white pizza from many many different places no one comes close to good guys white pizza. Excellent wings also

Good Guys Pizza
RN
Roger Nicosia
google
03.21.2017
5/5

My "go to " place since my pizza junction closed. It could be their old recipe but I don't know as I never had it before they closed. Lots of delicious sweet sauce, lots of cheese and pepperoni. I live in NC now so always have to get pizza there once or twice when I come to visit. We have nothing that even comes close!

Good Guys Pizza
AF
Adam French
google
03.13.2017
5/5

Fully loaded pizza. Would definitely recommend. 2 slices would fill pretty much anyone up.

Good Guys Pizza
CH
Cathleen Hurley
google
01.24.2017
5/5

Food is always excellent. When i ordered i was told 40 min and waited close to an hour for my pick up order. It was worth the wait!

Good Guys Pizza
VH
Vinny Harr Prints
google
01.22.2017
5/5

Best blue cheese east and west of Buffalo.

Good Guys Pizza
BH
Bradley Hepburn
google
01.17.2017
5/5

I grew up eating this pizza when I was a kid... Almost 40 years later and it's still the best. Hard to find a place that offers consistently high quality across decades and generations. Keep it up Good Guys and thanks for the memories!

Good Guys Pizza
LW
Larry Woods
google
01.17.2017
5/5

When you want good thick Pizza go to Good Guys

Good Guys Pizza
AS
Anthony Sanders
google
11.10.2016
5/5

Great food. Quick and always ready when they say that it will be done. Could hold back on the lettuce a little bit though.

Good Guys Pizza
AG
Anthony Giunta
google
10.04.2016
4/5

Simply the best pizza around NT. Just count your change and check your receit ;)

Good Guys Pizza
NM
Nick Mrzygut
google
08.16.2016
5/5

I consider myself a pizza & wing connoisseur. I've tried hundreds of places. This is by far the best. Super thick cheese, tons of sauce, and the crust is deliciously buttery. The wings are just as amazing, huge, crispy but not dry. Do yourself a favor and stop by this place.

Good Guys Pizza
RA
Rainbows And Kittens
google
08.13.2016
5/5

This place is great. You can't mess with anything they offer all the way down to the blue cheese.

Good Guys Pizza
SB
Sue B
google
06.18.2016
5/5

One of my favorite pizza joints. At least 2-3 times a year we make a 45 minute drive (one way) for a half a sheet and an order of fries!

Good Guys Pizza
KF
Katie F
google
05.20.2016
5/5

Literally best pizza EVERRRRR!

Good Guys Pizza
YP
Yvonne Perez
google
04.19.2016
5/5

NY style Pizza is my favorite on the menu. Staff goes above and beyond !

Good Guys Pizza
JF
Jacqueline Fontana
google
04.18.2016
5/5

Place has awesome food and we'll worth what they charge for subs pizza wings and everything else..love this place

Good Guys Pizza
TR
Theresa Rayner
google
03.08.2016
5/5

Always excellent.. Its our stay-datenight go to meal. Never disappoints

Good Guys Pizza
TB
Tim Buchanan
google
02.23.2016
5/5

Worth the drive from Amherst (UB campus). Best pizza in the area (and great wings).

Good Guys Pizza
KS
Kelsey Sholtz
google
02.12.2016
5/5

Great food and great service. Definitely worth a try.

Good Guys Pizza
SB
Sharon Broeker Broeker
google
02.08.2016
5/5

First time there. The subs were great.

Good Guys Pizza
AB
Andria Baunee
google
01.22.2016
5/5

Really good pizza! They do not deliver and they take a full 40 minutes to craft the perfect pizza and IT'S WORTH EVERY MINUTE! This place gets busy, but they are consistent in prep time and food quality. Go here for great pizza!

Good Guys Pizza
WC
William Chase
google
01.03.2016
5/5

great pizza and subs, owners and employees always make sure your order is right and on time. generous portions at decent prices they are not out to gouge the customer, best French fries in the area

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 17166951592

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!